How Youth Soccer Clubs Can Mentor Coaches In-House
A youth soccer club mentors coaches in-house by giving each assistant coach a specific, repeatable job instead of a vague title, then building two short habits around every practice, a quick briefing beforehand and a quick debrief after. That structure does more for a developing coach over a season than a weekend clinic ever will.
I co-founded Train Daily and coach youth soccer in Fort Wayne, IN, and the two assistant coaches on my staff didn't turn into real coaches because of a license or a weekend clinic. They turned into real coaches because I gave each of them one specific job and built a few minutes of structure around every practice to go with it.
Most clubs talk about coach development as a problem to solve with more clinics, more certifications, or a thicker rulebook. Those things help, but they aren't what changes a volunteer parent into someone who can run a session with a dozen nine-year-olds without needing you standing over his shoulder. Repetition does that, and repetition only happens if a club builds the structure to make it automatic.
What does an in-house coach mentoring program look like?
A working mentoring program has three parts. Every assistant gets a defined role. Every practice includes a short conversation before and after it. And a club leader checks in on both the role and the conversations instead of assuming they're happening on their own.
Most clubs that try to mentor coaches skip straight to the hardest part, teaching tactics, and skip the easiest part, giving someone a job they can do well on day one. Tell a new assistant to "help out" and they'll stand near the cones and watch. Tell them "you own the passing station for the next six weeks" and they'll show up prepared, because the job has an edge to it.
Why do coach mentoring programs fail before they start?
Most break down for one of two reasons. The club asks an experienced coach to "mentor" without giving him a block of time on the calendar to do it, so it never happens. Or the club runs a training session for new coaches once a year and expects it to stick, when a volunteer who coaches two hours a week needs reinforcement every week, not once a year.
The fix isn't more content. It's a schedule. If a club doesn't attach the mentoring relationship to something that already happens on a fixed cadence, like every practice or every game, it competes with everything else on a volunteer's calendar and loses.
How do you turn an assistant coach title into a real role?
Start by splitting the job into pieces that don't require running the whole practice. On my staff, assistant coaches Patrick Sordelet and Erik Preus follow my lead on anything tactical, but each of them owns a specific piece of the session. One runs a parallel station during drills, so two things can happen on the field at once instead of a dozen players standing in one line. The other owns a single observation focus during scrimmages, watching one thing like first touch, shape, or who's calling for the ball, instead of trying to track everything at once. Both handle setup and teardown, and on game day, one of them keeps the printed game sheet.
None of those jobs require designing a practice plan or explaining a tactic to a parent on the sideline. They require showing up and doing one thing well, which is exactly the kind of job a developing coach can succeed at from week one. The role builds the confidence that eventually lets them take on more.
What should a pre-practice briefing cover?
A pre-practice briefing should take 60 to 90 seconds and cover what's different about the next session, not everything in the plan. On my team, this happens the day before practice. I tell Patrick and Erik what's changing from the standard structure, which station needs extra attention, and anything about a specific player that matters that day.
Keep it short on purpose. A 20-minute pre-practice meeting is a different kind of task, one most volunteer coaches won't make time for every week. A 90-second version fits into a text message or a conversation at pickup, which means it happens. If a club doesn't already have a repeatable way to plan each practice, building that structure first makes a briefing like this far easier to run.
What should happen in a post-practice or postgame debrief?
A good debrief takes one to three minutes, happens on the field right after the session ends, and answers one question, what did we notice that we should carry into next time. On my team, this happens as a short conversation with Patrick and Erik before anyone leaves the field.
It isn't a performance review. It's a habit of noticing out loud. An assistant who watched first touch all practice might say a specific player is rushing passes under pressure. Twenty seconds of talking about that, on the spot, teaches an assistant coach more about what to look for than a season of silently standing next to the same head coach would.
How do you mentor a coach who didn't grow up playing soccer at a high level?
Tell them the gap closes with repetition, not talent. I didn't grow up playing high-level soccer myself, and I learned a lot of what I know standing next to an experienced coach before I ever ran a practice on my own. The same path works for anyone a club is trying to develop.
A coach who's unsure of their own ability needs two things from a mentor, a specific job they can do well immediately, and permission to ask questions without it costing them credibility with the team. Pair them with someone willing to walk through why a decision got made, not only what the decision was, and give them six weeks in one role before asking them to take on another.
If the coach you're mentoring feels unqualified standing in front of a group of kids who've played longer than he has, that feeling is normal and it fades with reps, not with a certificate. My post on coaching soccer without having played at a high level yourself goes deeper into building that confidence from scratch.
How do you keep coaching consistent across every team in a club?
Share infrastructure. A shared philosophy isn't enough on its own. At the club where I coach, program coordinators Zach and Shelly Netherton run a warm-up shared across three different teams, so every player on those rosters starts practice the same way no matter which coach is running that day's session. That consistency didn't come from a memo. It came from building one piece of the practice that every team uses without needing to reinvent it.
A club-wide mentoring structure works the same way. Pick one or two pieces every team runs identically, a warm-up, a cue library, a way of opening a scrimmage, and build those first. New coaches don't need a 14,000-word curriculum to read before their first practice. They need two or three things already decided for them, so they can focus on learning the job instead of inventing the whole session from scratch.
A mentoring structure works best when every coach is teaching from the same plan instead of improvising week to week. My post on building a season-long practice curriculum covers how to set that plan once so new coaches aren't inventing sessions from scratch.
What does a mentoring structure cost a club to run?
Almost nothing in dollars, and a real amount of calendar time from whoever runs it. The briefing-and-debrief structure above costs a few minutes per coach per week. What it requires is a club leader willing to protect that time the same way they'd protect a practice slot on the field.
Some clubs add a coach-education budget on top of that structure, things like video libraries or outside clinics. That's useful, but it isn't the part that changes a new coach's Tuesday night practice. The habits around every session are. The same approach works for keeping players working at home between practices, a few minutes of structure beats a one-time push every time.
Off-day consistency across a roster is the same problem as coach consistency. It only works if the structure makes it easy. Train Daily lets a coach assign off-day reps in about two minutes and see who did the work, across every team in the club, without adding another app for a volunteer to manage.
Pick one assistant coach this week and give them a single job they own for the next six weeks. Add a 90-second conversation before their next practice and a two-minute one after it. That's the whole program to start, and it's enough to turn a coach who's standing around into one who's running the session instead of standing next to you.
Frequently asked questions
Do you need a director of coaching to mentor assistant coaches?
No. A head coach can run this structure with no formal title or budget. The parts that matter are a defined role for each assistant and a short conversation before and after practice. A director of coaching helps a club apply the same structure across every team, but one coach can start it with a single assistant tomorrow.
How long should a coaching briefing or debrief take?
A pre-practice briefing should run 60 to 90 seconds and cover what's changing from the standard plan. A postgame or post-practice debrief should run one to three minutes and focus on one thing worth carrying into next time. Longer than that, and most volunteer coaches stop doing it every week.
How many assistant coaches does a youth team need?
One is enough to start. Two works well for a roster of 10 to 14 players, since it lets a head coach split observation duties during scrimmages and share setup and game-day tasks. The number matters less than whether each assistant has a specific job instead of a general one.
Can a new coach mentor someone else once they've developed?
Yes, and that's the point. A coach who spent a season owning one role and getting regular feedback is ready to mentor the next new assistant the same way. The structure is what scales, not any one person's experience level.
What if a club can't afford a formal coach development program?
It doesn't need one. The briefing-and-debrief structure costs time, not money. A club with zero budget for coach education can still build this by protecting a few minutes around every practice and game, and holding every coach, paid or volunteer, accountable for using that time instead of skipping it when things get busy.